Top 10 Local Restaurants in Broken Arrow (2024)

Broken Arrow city in Oklahoma that once started as an agricultural hub that produced coal has presently gained a lot of popularity with its diverse tourist attractions, with numerous locations to visit the city also has a selection of cuisine that you try during your trip to Broken Arrow. Here is a list of some of the top local restaurants in Broken Arrow that you should walk into to experience the taste of local variety.

Top 10 Local Restaurants in Broken Arrow

Here is a list of some of the best restaurants to try in Broken Arrow:

1. Smokies Hickory House:

Smokies Hickory House is an authentic, original barbecue restaurant in Broken Arrow that serves pulled pork, ribs, and other dishes. Vegetarians won’t find much food on the menu, which is small and primarily for meat lovers. The classic tri-factor of onion rings, fried pickles, or firecrackers are offered as appetizers and sides (similar to spicy fries).

The meats available include grilled chicken, hog, beef brisket, and hot and cold links (a sort of sausage). A carnivore’s feast, there is a choice of exquisite seasoning mixes as well as the possibility of a three-meat combination. Do visit and enjoy one of the top local restaurants in Broken Arrow

Timings: Monday – Thursday 11 am to 8:00 pm. Friday – Saturday 11 am to 8:30 pm.

2. Billy Sims’ BBQ:

Billy Sims, a well-known American football player, founded and owns Billy Sims’ BBQ, a BBQ restaurant that specializes in northern-style dishes, featuring sauces and rubs from Memphis and Oklahoma. Big dinners, hot dogs, and a variety of mouth-watering sides are all available as menu choices. Sims had a football background; therefore, the restaurant has a clear football motif with wall-to-wall paintings and collectibles. All kinds of barbecued meats, including pulled pig, slow-cooked brisket, including both chicken and turkey and smoked poultry, are available as main dishes. Classic sides including potato salad, corn on the cob, and BBQ beans are offered. It is a perfect place for you to find your personal taste.

Timings: Monday to Saturday – 11 am to 9 pm; Sunday – 11 am to 8 pm.

3. Main Street Tavern:

Even though the Main Street Tavern is a sports pub in Broken Arrow, visitors shouldn’t be turned off by that fact. While there is a bustling atmosphere, the food is of really excellent quality. The Main Street Tavern’s handmade meat loaf and its inventive macaroni cheese, which combines fresh shellfish with a rich cheese sauce over pasta, are among the restaurant’s main courses. For those who prefer meat, the menu also offers a selection of steaks, chops, and hamburgers. The dessert menu is a little less extensive than the main meal but still features all-American favorites like apple pie, triple chocolate cake, and raspberry cheesecake. Walk into one of the top local restaurants in Broken Arrow with your friends and family to enjoy the beautiful meal.

Timings: Monday to Thursday – 11 am to 10 pm; Friday to Saturday – 10 am to 12 am; Sunday – 10 am to 10 pm.

4. Jimmy’s Eggs:

For the past thirty years, Jimmy’s Egg has already been offering up delicious meals in Broken Arrow. Surprisingly, the restaurant-diner offers eggs as a specialty, prepared in a variety of ways. Jimmy’s Egg will assist in preparing anything the reservation is made, including omelets, pancakes, eggs over-easy, and more. The classic breakfast option can be made just how you want it with choices for meat, egg type, toast, and pancakes. Ribeye and sirloin steaks, as well as bacon or ham steaks, are among the delectable meats that are offered. Ensure to arrive early because servings are large and intended to last the entire day.

Timings: Everyday 6 am to 2 pm.

5. Ted’s Cafe Escondido:

If you are into Mexican food, then you are at the correct place. Every day, Ted’s Café Escondido delivers delicious Mexican variety. Along with more classic Tex-Mex cuisine, the menu offers signature dishes. Slowly adding new locations for the restaurant, all of which will be in Oklahoma. Ted’s signature dishes include homemade tamales stuffed with shredded beef or creamy chicken. For those who can’t decide, the house tacos include a mix of chicken and beef, which is a terrific option. Items like chimichangas, burritos, or even Monterey style grilled chicken are available as lunch specials. A tasty midday snack, the tender chicken breast is roasted with a variety of spices and cheese. check out all the dishes you can in one of the top local restaurants in Broken Arrow while you are in the city.

Timings: Monday to Thursday – 11 am to 9 pm; Friday to Saturday – 11 am to 10 pm; Sunday – 11 am to 8:30 pm.

6. Ti Amo:

This restaurant in Broken Arrow is among the unique sophisticated places, following Mediterranean and Italian style, it offers a diverse selection of mouthwatering dishes such as meat dishes, pizza, pasta, and steaks. A top-quality veal steak is used in veal alla Tuscany, which is a rich dish made with prosciutto, peppers, and mushrooms in a brandy-based sauce. Dinner also includes a dish called bistecca e gamberi, an Italian twist on the traditional surf and turf that combines a wonderful steak with large prawns.

Timings: Sunday – closed; Monday to Friday – 11 am to 2 pm; and 5 pm To 9 pm in the evenings.

7. Villa Ravenna:

Just a few kilometers away from Broken Arrow lies the privately owned and family-run Italian eatery Villa Ravenna. Third generation Italian restaurant owners that draw influence from their grandparents and parents who before them run the establishment. A gorgonzola and pear salad and burrata, a creamier and more opulent variation on mozzarella cheese, are both specialties on the menu. Veal osso bucco, a slow-roasted piece of veal in a rich sauce, is one of the main courses. Villa Ravenna, which specializes in game, also provides a version of the dish cinghiale osso bucco, which features wild pig.

Timings: Monday – closed; Tuesday to Saturday – 11 am to 2 pm and 5 pm to 9 pm in the evenings.

8. Mc Gill’s:

Greg McGill and Hal Walker opened their restaurant in 1991, and for the past 20 years, they have been providing excellent meals to Tulsans and potential visitors in in Broken Arrow. At McGill’s, the supper menu is divided between comfort food and elegant dishes that are ideal for a special occasion. There are a variety of choices for meat eaters as well, but the restaurant’s signature dish is a velvety lobster and pasta dish. With chicken, cream, mushrooms, and sinfully sweet marsala wine, the chicken marsala is a stunning dish. Both locals and visitors will love the food, which makes excellent use of fresh, local ingredients. Therefore, it is one of the top local restaurants in Broken Arrow.

Timings: Sunday to Monday – closed; Tuesday to Thursday – 5 pm to 9 pm; Friday to Saturday – 5 pm to 10 pm.

9. Shiloh’s of Broken Arrow:

For more than five generations, Shiloh’s of Broken Arrow has been a restaurant in the city. It is a family-run establishment that offers a wide selection of both lunch and dinner selections in addition to offering breakfast all day. One of the dinner options is a bacon-wrapped hamburger steak, which consists of ground beef patties that are fried with bacon before being covered in grilled onions. Grilled shrimp, fried shrimp, and roasted salmon are offered to guests and diners who enjoy fish. Big, belly-busting omelets are the ideal way to start the day, and the breakfasts are known for both their size and excellence.

Timings: Sunday to Wednesday – 8 am to 3 pm; Thursday to Saturday – 8 am to 3 pm.

10. Rattlesnake Cafe:

A very cozy coffee house that serves coffee, burritos, paninis, and wraps with vegan and plenty of other options. An ideal match for your short catch ups with your pals and getting your work done. Weekend Waffles for breakfast or a Tomato Pesto Panini for lunch go well with an ice-cold Chai Latte. Walk into the cafe to experience a chic space experience.

Timings: Sunday to Monday – 7 am to 2 pm; Tuesday to Saturday – 7 am to 5 pm.

So, the next time you visit Broken Arrow, give your tummy a treat that it’ll love. Pick any of these restaurants that are likely to your taste or to your fancy. Enjoy and have fun with your family and friends in these top local restaurants in Broken Arrow.